Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Standardized Tests and the Element.


Upon reading the section of chapter two that talked about the SAT's and other standardized tests, I realized that I totally agree. Even before I got to college and started taking classes in education, I knew that standardized tests were not my forte and didn't accurately assess my intelligence. They only test a small spectrum of intelligence which only includes math, reading and writing. Our government has forced standardized tests that only test this small spectrum of intelligence. Legislation is forcing us to put so much emphasis on these three that we are, in essesnce, making students throughout the country feel that they are less intelligent or more intelligent then they might otherwise be if the test was based on something that they were actually good at. Many students do not excel in the three that are tested and are otherwise prevented from going to the college of their choice or at all. Some colleges aren't looking at the SAT as closely as they used to but they still ask you for that number. How are students to find their Element when they must spend most of their time and energy on standardized tests that only test the big three? They are now starting to test some other subjects but they are still only testing subjects that students still do not fully understand or do not care to fully understand. How do we help students find their Element around all of these standardized tests? I wish I had an answer to this question but I hope that one day, together as a team, educators can come together and find a solution so everyone might find a calling.

Tuesday, February 16, 2010

The Element & Opportunity

Robinson defines the element as "the place where the things we love to do and the things we are good at come together" (p. xiii). How much more productive and efficient would our workforce be if more of the population operated within their "element"? Yet, it seems so unlikely, almost impossible, that people can discover their "element" in spite of the many obstacles and factors that confine us to our current situations--location, finances, family obligations, lack of opportunity, etc. Does everyone have the potential to excel at something to the extent of the individuals Robinson uses as examples in his book? Robinson will most likely reveal to us that those in their "element" have overcome challenges to devote themselves entirely to the passion that drives them. "They pursued them because they couldn't imagine doing anything else with their lives" (p. 20). He gives the example of the keyboard player who had practiced 3-4 hours every day from the age of 7 in addition to performing. Those in their "element" find the opportunity to do what they love, or create an opportunity where one doesn't exist.

Monday, February 15, 2010

True Calling Process

omg elements is under attack!!!Image by tommy the pariah via Flickr

Here's a link I found on the IUP alumni question/answer site on LinkedIn, maybe clarifies the way to FIND your purpose: http://www.biglinkrally.com
The Element explained ways of recognizing your purpose or being in the element. Those ways sounded a lot like the themes I found in my dissertation research about creating a new identity after a work transition.
--a sense of belonging (the dancer's group)
--purpose
--peers' reflection of us
--vision (Mick Fleetwood)My dissertation is at: http://tinyurl.com/HESSDISSERTATION
Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

The Element Week 1

As I started reading this book, I had almost a knot in my stomach! The thought of exploring these ideas that may lead me to my Element is exciting and scary at the same time. I am anxious to explore these theories and wonder what I am going to discover about myself, as well as my future students! On pg 3, where the author is describing the conversation between the mother and the psychologist, I thought to myself, "would I have thought that about a child acting that way? That she was graceful?" I fear that if a child were acting that way in my class I would ask them to sit still!! What are we suppressing in our students? Are we doing the right thing for them? How can we ever know what our impacts are having on them? I wonder if I will ever know the full impact of my actions on how my life turned out. I have to say, this book is causing me to look very deep into myself, and i'm only on the third chapter!

The Element

Can't wait for the book discussions to begin. Have already had one discussion with Joe Lander and we haven't officially met yet! The Element looks like it is going to be as good as Outliers. I sent you all emails about blogging and Twitter. Included were some links and tutorials that may help you. PLEASE let me know if you need some help. See you Wednesday, Feb. 17th at 2:40.

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Week 7

I am not able to be there for the discussion on the last part of the book, although I wish I could make it b/c that's when it makes the most sense to me. In the last part of the book, the author was discussing charter schools. He was telling how these different types of schools can benefit students who are just not succeeding in pubic schools. I was wondering where the closest charter school was to Oil City? I think that maybe I have heard of one in Tionesta, but that could be incorrect. If there is one nearby, I would like to see the research on it. I would like to see what students they are reaching, and how that school has helped them more than a public school. It seems that if this sort of information can be proven, then why are we not implementing their theories in public schools? Why should charter schools have all the fun? I understand that funding is a big part of it, but can't we receive more funding if we have students achieve success on the PSSA? What is it about these schools that make their students more successful than ours? How can we compete with that? I guess my blog contains more questions than answers. I've enjoyed the discussions on this book and look forward to future books!

Monday, January 25, 2010

Cause & Effect

A giant grouper at the Georgia Aquarium, seen ...Image via Wikipedia


Chapter 7, p. 161 talks about education research. The current research climate is effective in finding correlations, but not in causality. A better approach, the authors say, is to understand individual students in different circumstances.



But: Maybe we are looking at the wrong constructs, or through the wrong lenses?

It's ironic that the authors want to try to understand individuals but they use a scientific method to do this. A method that doesn't allow these individuals to TELL their individual stories.
Quantitative methods only place people as numbers, objects. Their stories--the things that we can use to understand why they do what they do, what they want to accomplish, what problems they are having--those go unnoted.

Qualitative methods like phenomenology would allow resaerchers to study aspects of one 'problem' that is going on in education. They can then see all the parts, understand the inner workings, and allow the individuals involved a voice.
The authors put a lot of stress on causality. But there are some things--especially when dealing with people and politics--that do not follow a predicatable casue-and-effect line. The more we try to predict people's behavior, the more we might be wrong about those predictions.

"Give a man a fish and he will eat for a day. Teach a man to fish, and he will eat for a lifetime. But--Why are we FISHING?" That's what my professor Ian Baptiste asks. Why are we only staying with the type of educational research methods we've always been using--and then wondering why things aren't working?

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]